Tag: Proliferation

  • Havana Syndrome and the Proliferation Question: Who Else Could Have Directed-Energy Weapons?

    For years, the debate over Havana syndrome has returned to a question about Russia. Was Moscow behind some of the unexplained episodes reported by American diplomats and intelligence officers overseas? In an interview with Katie Pavlich on NewsNation, the investigative journalist Catherine Herridge raised a question that would remain even if investigators could answer the first. If a device capable of causing those effects exists, how widely has the technology spread? Herridge said her reporting suggested that several groups were using it.

    Herridge expects a classified House Intelligence Committee report to examine whether a foreign adversary was responsible for some incidents and whether the technology has reached “other entities.” An unclassified version, she said, was awaiting a security review. The prospect of wider access will draw particular attention from people who identify as targeted individuals, many of whom say their accounts have been dismissed. If the committee finds that the technology has spread, it would widen the range of actors investigators might consider when a case has credible evidence of exposure. For now, the claim that multiple groups are using it rests on Herridge’s reporting. Investigators would still need evidence linking a device to any individual case.

    The accounts Herridge described suggest where that inquiry might begin. Some U.S. personnel told her they experienced incidents abroad and again after returning home. She reported that patients with suspected Havana syndrome were receiving care at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center and that, in some accounts, dogs reacted before their owners noticed anything unusual. Her sources also described an alleged sequence of “priming” and “finishing” attacks, with the later episodes said to cause more lasting harm. That sequence remains unverified. A National Institutes of Health study found no significant evidence of MRI-detectable brain injury in the group it examined, even though some participants experienced severe and persistent symptoms.

    The potential consequences reach beyond the people who reported symptoms. Herridge argued that even a small number of confirmed attacks could make intelligence agencies harder to recruit for and harder to stay in. She also warned that employees with high-level clearances who can no longer work could become more vulnerable to foreign recruitment if they are left in financial distress. That remains a hypothetical risk. The difficulties of getting help are documented. Federal auditors found that patients struggled to understand how to access care, and the HAVANA Act authorizes payments for certain qualifying injuries.

    The public report could give this debate a firmer footing by explaining what investigators know about the devices themselves, who may have obtained them and whether they can tie any device to a specific incident. It could also spell out what evidence would warrant opening a new case, including one reported by someone outside government. For people who have spent years asking how their accounts could be investigated, that may be the most consequential part of the proliferation question.